Skip to main content

Wall Street Journal: Centrist Democrats Try to Tame Far Left

November 16, 2026
News Article

Moderates drove blue wave, now seek to deter proposals viewed as lofty

DENVER—James Talarico stood before hundreds of Democrats who gathered here to plot a new course for their party and called for Congress to pass an agenda as bold as Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society.

“We have a mandate the size of Texas,” said Talarico, who won an upset victory in the state’s Senate race. He ticked off universal health coverage, a national ban on gerrymandering and other policy ambitions during his remarks on Thursday.

But he and other incoming lawmakers who campaigned on lofty proposals face a challenging reality. The Democrats’ new House and Senate majorities are built on centrist candidates who won House districts and states that only two years ago voted for President Trump. That will make moderates the most powerful force in the next Congress and a likely check on the party’s most left-wing impulses.

These centrists are looking for immediate, if less transformative, policy wins to show the swing voters and Trump supporters who helped elect them that they are focused on cost-of-living issues.

“We can have the wish list, but we need to make sure that we’re focused on a task list, that is, things we know we can deliver,” said Rep.-elect Paige Cognetti, the mayor of Scranton, Pa., who flipped a Republican--held House district that Trump had carried by more than eight percentage points in 2024.

The unifying goals that emerged in conversations among new and veteran lawmakers this past week include a ban on stock trading by House and Senate members—a response to anger over perceived self-dealing in government— and reversing cuts to Medicaid and Affordable Care Act subsidies that Trump and the Republican- led Congress approved.

A higher federal minimum wage and a bill to ease labor union organizing also arose as top priorities in discussions at the conference held in Denver, sponsored by a group called Majority Democrats, and which organizers said drew more than 3,500 people.

At least 55 Democrats won House districts in the mid--terms that Trump carried two years ago, including 37 who won seats now held by Republicans. It is the largest group in 20 years of Democrats from districts that backed the GOP in the prior presidential election. They will account for more than one in five Democrats in the next Congress.

The party’s unexpected gain of eight Senate seats, with hopes of picking up a ninth seat once the tally is final in Alaska, also rests in large part on centrist candidates winning in states Trump carried. Talarico, for example, promised to stand up to his party to defend oil- and gas-industry jobs, and he didn’t endorse a Medicare for All system that replaces private insurance, a top progressive priority.

Already, many in the party are thinking about how to retain the political real estate they have won, saying Democrats in the next election can’t count on Trump to generate the same voter anger that hurt GOP candidates this year.

Rep. Tom Suozzi (D., N.Y.), who won re-election in a district that Trump carried by about four points in 2024, said the overwhelming majority of Democrats who flipped Republican House districts were centrists who would face competitive races in 2028. He cautioned the party against picking up progressive policy goals, such as the call to abolish U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, known as ICE.

“Those are some of the stupidest words ever in the history of politics,” he said. “Right after, ‘defund the police.’ ” He also saw Medicare for All as the wrong approach to expand health coverage. “The objective is a noble objective, but it’s not going to happen politically,” he said.

One sign of the power of centrists comes from the New Democrat Coalition, the party’s moderate caucus in the House. The group says it will have 142 members next year, up from 114 now, meaning it will include more than half of all Democratic House members and will be a formidable voice on legislation.

“We’re the majority-makers,” said Rep. Nikki Budzinski (D., Ill.), the group’s new leader. “We’re the Democrats who run in red areas and purple areas, and we win, and we stay focused on policy that speaks to most people in America, who are in the middle.”

The left-wing Congressional Progressive Caucus says it is gaining 25 new members, several of whom also joined centrist or conservative caucuses. It will include more than 100 lawmakers, including several who call themselves Democratic socialists.

Most of the new members are from solidly Democratic communities, but about six won districts Trump carried in 2024. They include Randy Villegas, a college professor who won 68% of the vote in a California district Trump carried by two points.

“What we have proven in my election is that you can win with a progressive populist platform, not just in safe blue seats but in swing districts anywhere across this country,” Villegas said at a progressive caucus event this month.

Other incoming members of the progressive caucus said they would push for a range of new and enhanced social programs. “We have a system right now that is rigged for the elite and the wealthy,” said Daniel Koh, newly elected in a heavily Democratic district in Massachusetts. He promised to “unrig the system” by raising taxes on corporations and high-income earners.

“It means taking that money and making sure that we cap people’s rent, cap their utility bills, free child care, reinstituting the child tax credit, and, finally, passing Medicare for All,” he said. Koh carried a district that Trump lost by 20 points.